Consultation & inquiry responses

We regularly respond to government consultations and parliamentary inquiries on a range of environmental and scientific topics, individually or in partnership with other organisations. We focus on synthesising and communicating the relevant ecological evidence, and representing the views of the ecological community.

Submitting high-quality responses relies on the expertise of our members. If you would like to contribute to consultations and inquiries, please register on our Interests and Expertise Database, or contact Brendan Costelloe, Policy Manager.

BES Scottish Policy Group response to the stakeholder questionnaire from the Grouse Moor Management Group

September 2018

(456 KB pdf)

The BES Scottish Policy Group’s approach to the questionnaire is in line with the BES position: to make the best scientific evidence accessible to decision-makers and is based on the expertise of our membership. We have responded to a select number of questions concerning raptor conservation and predation management, muirburn, and mountain hares – where our answers can be supported by evidence.

Download BES Scottish Policy Group response to the stakeholder questionnaire from the Grouse Moor Management Group pdf

BES Scottish Policy Group response to the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee’s call for evidence on the Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill

August 2018

(297 KB pdf)

Our approach is to provide context in terms of the likely impacts of climate change on Scotland’s natural environment. This shows why urgency is required to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and why adaptation as part of the Climate Change Plan is as important as mitigation to protect Scotland’s biodiversity, ecosystems and habitats.

Download BES Scottish Policy Group response to the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee’s call for evidence on the Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill pdf

2018

BES Scottish Policy Group response to the Scottish Government's consultation: Support for agriculture and the rural economy - post Brexit transition

August 2018

(378 KB pdf)

This consultation is the start of the Scottish Government’s process to develop a new rural support policy for Scotland. It presents both an opportunity and a challenge to create a sustainable agricultural system that is better balanced for farming, food production, the countryside, wildlife, and the delivery of public goods. Public goods connected to the environment include for example, clean air and water, healthy and stable soils, improved/enhanced carbon sequestration, biodiversity and healthy ecosystems.

Download BES Scottish Policy Group response to the Scottish Government's consultation: Support for agriculture and the rural economy - post Brexit transition pdf

BES response to the Changing Arctic inquiry

May 2018

(424 KB pdf)

Our response explained how climate change is shifting the Arctic to a ‘new normal’, characterised by a warmer, wetter and more variable environment and reduced volume of the sea and land-based ice. Climate change also interacts with other major threats to Arctic ecosystems, including pollution, invasive alien species, industrial development and local disturbances. These environmental pressures are driving major physical and ecological change.

Download BES response to the Changing Arctic inquiry pdf

BES response to the Work of Defra: Health and Harmony inquiry

April 2018

(430 KB pdf)

The BES welcomes the Health and Harmony: the future for food, farming and the environment in a Green Brexit consultation as an opportunity to reshape England’s land management policies. A move away from incentives which primarily prioritise provisioning services from the environment, such as food and fibre, towards incentives which also include regulating, supporting, and cultural ecosystem services, such as disease and pest regulation and soil formation, will provide a better outcome for both people and wildlife.

 

Download BES response to the Work of Defra: Health and Harmony inquiry pdf

BES response to Brexit: Plant and Animal Biosecurity Inquiry

April 2018

(389 KB pdf)

We believe there is the potential to reduce biosecurity threats to the UK through implementing better targeted, resourced, and stricter biosecurity rules and regulations.

 

Download BES response to Brexit: Plant and Animal Biosecurity Inquiry pdf

BES response to the Work of the Rural Payments Agency inquiry

March 2018

(418 KB pdf)

We believe the Rural Payments Agency’s (RPA) delivery of Agri-Environment Schemes should foster greater cooperation and collaboration between stakeholders to help deliver greater benefits for biodiversity and ecological services. Our response highlights how the RPA can put the environment at the heart of its work.

Download BES response to the Work of the Rural Payments Agency inquiry pdf

BES response to the Environmental Audit Committee 25 year plan to improve the environment inquiry

March 2018

(351 KB pdf)

Our response welcomed such a broad plan for the environment but highlighted that there were many unmeasurable and unambitious targets and that without legislation underpinning the intentions set out in the plan, it is unlikely to be enforced.

Download BES response to the Environmental Audit Committee 25 year plan to improve the environment inquiry pdf

2017

EEA workers in the UK labour market

November 2017

(187 KB pdf)

We contributed to the Royal Society of Biology’s response, which highlighted uncertainty over continued rights of EEA workers in the UK, issues over rights and status, the inflexibility of the current system, and the potential impact of immigration changes on the UK biosciences and industrial strategy.

Download EEA workers in the UK labour market pdf

Natural Environment and Rural Communities Act

A response to the House of Lords NERC Act Committee

September 2017

(348 KB pdf)

Our response highlighted the impact and limitations of the biodiversity duty introduced by the 2006 NERC Act, and how this could be amended in light of current understanding of biodiversity and ecosystems, as well as the legislative challenges posed by Brexit.

Download Natural Environment and Rural Communities Act pdf